Well today I called a few appraisers from appraisers1.com listings, and the majority were happy with the service and have gotten at least one assignment. Out of the 6 that I called, 4 said they would renew after a year, and the other 2 said they would consider it after their contract is up to see how much business it brought them.
One of the guys I talked to told me that he has been with them for 3 years, and as the years go by, the website has gotten more popular. He wasn't sure that he was getting any extra business from signing up, until he started asking his clients how they found him, and it turned out that 3 people in the 2nd year found him on appraisers1.com.
So after talking with that guy a while, I called appraisers1.com and talked to an area director, and asked a few questions about what separates them from their competition. The main thing was that they actively send out your information to lenders both in your area, and around the country. They also have incentive programs for lenders to use their appraisers, such as a chance to win $250 for going with an appraiser on the site. They also advertise their site in several ways, such as in the NMB magazine, emails, calls, faxes, etc around the country.
The other aspect of the site that I liked was that their listings for each county are rotated each time someone visits, so each listing gets equal exposure. I know that appraisers.com doesn't do this, which is the main reason I wouldn't sign up with them.
Does anyone have any info on other directory sites about what separates them from other sites?