moh malekpour
Elite Member
- Joined
- May 25, 2002
- Professional Status
- Certified Residential Appraiser
- State
- California
Brad,The first part of that can be so wrong it is laughable.
1) If the P/E is lower than the industry average then the stock is underperforming? Not always at all
Save your laugh for this quiz because you may have to laugh at yourself. I am going to give you or anyone else who has experience in stock evaluation and rating to compare the following P/E of 6 companies from the same industry and tell me which one is outperforming and which one is under performing in comparison to others. I am not going to name those companies but they are the same sector and I will give you the names if you want after you compared and rated them.
1-P/E=0.140
2-P/E=6.284
3-P/E=8.527
4-P/E=9.177
5-P/E=10.478
6-P/E=11.802
According to your logic of rating, the #1 & #2 should be the best performing and #5 & #6 should be the worst performing. Is that what you think?
Buffet is a contrarian investor. He buys under performed stocks. He never buys out performed stocks that are doing well. He buys stocks that are close to oblivion and nurture them. That is a different thing to buy a beat up stock of a company when it is down. but when we rate the current performance of the stock, the stock is under ferforming. Do all beat up stocks rebound? No . It needs Buffet to invest in them and Buffet does a through research and study to do that. He doesn’t buy any under performed stock.
Last edited: