• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

No, We Are Not Afraid Of Competition Etc. Trying To Help You

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bob Ipock

Elite Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2002
Professional Status
Certified Residential Appraiser
State
North Carolina
There have been several comments lately from people either wanting to take classes, taking classes now or finished with their classes. The common thread is usually they can't find a supervisor. Nobody is worried about you being a competitor....especially is you are hundreds or even thousands of miles apart. Even if you were in the same town it would be years before you could hurt e appraiser. We are not concerned about you being competition. This crap about not wanting to "give back to the profession". is offensive and wrong. Many of the folks on the forum give back freely.

There are far more reasons established appraisers will not take on a trainee than their are valid reasons to hire one. Believe me, if you are being trained right you will be costing your supervisor money for at least a year (probably more). The trainee slows everything down everything for a long time. It takes time to learn software, how to access public records, MLS etc. You will be constantly asking questions that eats up the supervisor's time. It will be a good long time until you could inspect a property without the supervisor. He or she is going to sign their name saying they inspected...and they damn well better. They will have to go WITH them in order to get your training hours.

Understand the split. Likely the MOST you would ever get would be 70/30.....and that would be way down the road. Let's say you get 50/50 On a $400 fee that would be $200. You would be lucky to get 4-5 in a weekly...in these times less. Some appraisers don't pay a split (I don't) but an hourly wage. I am not going to have a split until someone can do the entire appraisal without help. Where I am located a trainee must pay full dues for MLS access which is about $900.00 per year. At some point you will be responsible for paying for your own software. Don't forget the car expenses and I am talking tires, brakes, oil changes...because likely you will be racking up some miles.


If we could shake you...it would have been BEFORE you paid out for your classes and tell you to research the business in detail so you would know what you are getting in to. You can easily do some research and see that the number of appraisers is falling. The biggest pat of those people don't renew due to a lack of work. I know appraisers in there 70's and 80's who still have a license they may use on a limited basis.

I spoke with 4 appraiser buddies today, all in business 20+ years. All four said they were dead...no orders. It happens.....too frequently. None of the borrowers that bought at interest rates under 4%.....are not going to be refinancing at rates over 4%. Many appraisers depend of refinances for a bunch of their business.....I am in that column Fewer appraisals are being ordered, fees are stagnant at best. If you have a college degree of some technical skill.....there are plenty of other/better ways to make a living.

Don't come on here (or when speaking to an appraiser, sending out emails or making phone calls) and try to convince somebody that you know everything about the appraisal business....there is so much you need to know that can only be learned from a practicing appraiser. The fact that you did not find a supervisor or research the appraisal business before is evidence of what you did not know. New business is hard to get...it can be done .....but it is difficult. If you are going to get a new client it mean that someone is losing that client. There are many of us that have FIRED clients due to them being hard to deal with, low fees, dishonesty on their part etc.

I could go on....and hope some other appraisers on here might add some comments. It is not that we don't want to help you.....but we need to be honest with you. I hope you will be one of the 25% of trainees that are ever able to find a supervisor.


If this sounds harsh or discouraging that is only because it is the truth. Again, do not spend money on appraisal classes until you research the business and talk to 10 appraisers in your area to see if they need a trainee, already have a trainee of don't have enough work or the desire to take on a trainee.

Good luck. Remember we actually make our on luck.
 
Is it possible some trainees , instead hired by /working alongside an individual appraiser, are on boarded with AMC or mill shop and have a "supervisor" assigned that in reality barely interacts with them?

What is striking is a number of trainees posting seem to lack a supervisor to turn to, and are working on an assignment, floundering around turning here to help. It's okay to post for help, but whenever I ask where is your supervisor, no answer. We too floundered around in training but had a mentor/ supervisor to help us-
 
Last edited:
tell you to research the business in detail so you would know what you are getting in to.
Although I liked a bunch of what you said in your OP, USPAP, this part jumped out at me

I've had 4 people call me over the past 5 years (1 just within the past few weeks - he I have not taken out with me but did offer) asking about getting into this profession. All were very intelligent individuals with various degrees of professional backgrounds. The closest one I found with any real estate background was a female who had been working for a property managing company. The next "closest" was a guy who's father "owned some property"

All 4 I offered to take out with me for a "day in the life" (again, the 4th has not called back to take me up on the offer) I did not charge them anything for the time. I set it up so it was for vacant properties (lock box) that I didn't have to worry about time restraints, or borrowers/agents wondering what was going on, etc.

Yes, it was time consuming, but all seemed to appreciate it. All of them pretty much had the same reaction though regarding what went into an appraisal. They all thought it was just the "few minutes" at a property and BOOM you have a value and made $$$. Once I showed them the research side back at the office (very quick overview at that) and explained the "typing a report" ... :eyecrazy:
 
I don't advise anything here, make your own road.. but I did work for free for about 6 months back in 1982. It didn't matter though times were hard couldn't find a job anyway, so I used to hang out with and tag along with my appraiser friend measuring houses......The rest is history:mad2: Over 30 years and 3 fee shops later I must have trained 20 or so from scratch... but back then it didn't take 2 years or 2000 hours to properly train someone.. the smart ones new what they were doing in a couple of months...
 
Last edited:
Is it possible some trainees , instead hired by /working alongside an individual appraiser, are on boarded with AMC or mill shop and have a "supervisor" assigned that in reality barely interacts with them?

What is striking is a number of trainees posting seem to lack a supervisor to turn to, and are working on an assignment, floundering around turning here to help. It's okay to post for help, but whenever I ask where is your supervisor, no answer. We too floundered around in training but had a mentor/ supervisor to help us-

My main point is folks nee to look for that supervisor before they spend the money on the classes. My God, if I was going to consider going into a profession I would do a whole bunch of research on the front end. Too many instructors do not explain the facts the very first day or night of classes. If I was going to become a welder, electrician, stockbroker, CPA or plumber, I would certainly find out about the business beforehand. It would occur to me that most if not all of these folks that are looking for a supervisor should have done so before and during classes. It would also occur to me that they have few if any contacts or they would not be on here. I would hope the students would be discussing all this and sharing information and tips. Of course, if you are taking classes online you are going to really miss out. I had a student go through all 90 hours and ask me on the vry last night (exam night) if he conviction for selling herion would be an issue to get a license.
 
Although I liked a bunch of what you said in your OP, USPAP, this part jumped out at me

I've had 4 people call me over the past 5 years (1 just within the past few weeks - he I have not taken out with me but did offer) asking about getting into this profession. All were very intelligent individuals with various degrees of professional backgrounds. The closest one I found with any real estate background was a female who had been working for a property managing company. The next "closest" was a guy who's father "owned some property"

All 4 I offered to take out with me for a "day in the life" (again, the 4th has not called back to take me up on the offer) I did not charge them anything for the time. I set it up so it was for vacant properties (lock box) that I didn't have to worry about time restraints, or borrowers/agents wondering what was going on, etc.

Yes, it was time consuming, but all seemed to appreciate it. All of them pretty much had the same reaction though regarding what went into an appraisal. They all thought it was just the "few minutes" at a property and BOOM you have a value and made $$$. Once I showed them the research side back at the office (very quick overview at that) and explained the "typing a report" ... :eyecrazy:

That is really nice of you! And a good idea, and a service to working appraisers for exposing prospective trainees to "a day in the life". Until their day with you, they had no better idea of our work than do many homeowners, who really think that what they see of us is almost all we do.

Watching us do the rest in real time could be unexciting. Although... Norway has Slow TV and it is popular. You could be our representative if they did US Appraisers in real time. ;-)
 
If we could shake you...it would have been BEFORE you paid out for your classes and tell you to research the business in detail so you would know what you are getting in to. You can easily do some research and see that the number of appraisers is falling. The biggest pat of those people don't renew due to a lack of work. I know appraisers in there 70's and 80's who still have a license they may use on a limited basis.

From Jonathan Miller:

AI President lays out their 2018 Goals From Their Bubble

From Valuation Review‘s recap, Murrett spoke from his insulated cocoon. Here are his 2 main points, translated:

ONE Push residential appraisers to do $25 evaluations for reasons AI isn’t willing to share and then fog the situation by proclaiming it is necessary to follow regulatory rules and regulations:

“The use of evaluations isn’t the end of the world as long as appraisers are doing the evaluations,” Murrett said. “This, of course, falls in line with the regulatory rules and other regulations. We’d like to see appraisers do evaluations and not be in fear of violating USPAP requirements.”

TWO Continue to promote the false narrative that the appraisal population is falling when exam takers rose 20% last year and that the Bureau of Labor Statistics projects the appraiser population to grow 14% over the next decade:

“Another area of concern is the shrinking number of appraisers, whether it is the actual certification count by the Appraisal Subcommittee or the actual number of bodies which is what AI counts,” Murrett added. “The trend of incoming appraisers is still going down. We’re still an aging profession, and in the next 10 years as appraisers retire or pass away, the number of new appraisers entering the profession won’t be any larger.”
 
“The use of evaluations isn’t the end of the world as long as appraisers are doing the evaluations,” Murrett said. “This, of course, falls in line with the regulatory rules and other regulations. We’d like to see appraisers do evaluations and not be in fear of violating USPAP requirements.”

I assume that means the push to drop USPAP requirements from states allowing appraisers to do evaluation , and not have to be USPAP compliant when doing those evaluations?

But does USPAP ever really go away as a standard for appraisals?

What is the standard if they get regulators to drop USPAP for this area of practice,? If the is not obligated to follow USPAP, why not return to letting a RE agent or staff person do the BPO or evaluation? Why use an appraiser then ? used at that point? Some extra expertise we supposedly provide for the dinky fee? Will the appraiser's e and o cover them if they do a non USPAP compliant desktop appraisal?
 
From Jonathan Miller:

AI President lays out their 2018 Goals From Their Bubble

From Valuation Review‘s recap, Murrett spoke from his insulated cocoon. Here are his 2 main points, translated:

ONE Push residential appraisers to do $25 evaluations for reasons AI isn’t willing to share and then fog the situation by proclaiming it is necessary to follow regulatory rules and regulations:

“The use of evaluations isn’t the end of the world as long as appraisers are doing the evaluations,” Murrett said. “This, of course, falls in line with the regulatory rules and other regulations. We’d like to see appraisers do evaluations and not be in fear of violating USPAP requirements.”

TWO Continue to promote the false narrative that the appraisal population is falling when exam takers rose 20% last year and that the Bureau of Labor Statistics projects the appraiser population to grow 14% over the next decade:

“Another area of concern is the shrinking number of appraisers, whether it is the actual certification count by the Appraisal Subcommittee or the actual number of bodies which is what AI counts,” Murrett added. “The trend of incoming appraisers is still going down. We’re still an aging profession, and in the next 10 years as appraisers retire or pass away, the number of new appraisers entering the profession won’t be any larger.”
I don't believe that BS. If it is true those exam takers are not finding jobs...the ASC count continues to drop and I know for certain the trainee count is down in some states.
 
I don't believe that BS. If it is true those exam takers are not finding jobs...the ASC count continues to drop and I know for certain the trainee count is down in some states.

Are these exam takers finding jobs? I get calls and emails every month from folks looking for a job. In addition theere people
Is it possible some trainees , instead hired by /working alongside an individual appraiser, are on boarded with AMC or mill shop and have a "supervisor" assigned that in reality barely interacts with them?

What is striking is a number of trainees posting seem to lack a supervisor to turn to, and are working on an assignment, floundering around turning here to help. It's okay to post for help, but whenever I ask where is your supervisor, no answer. We too floundered around in training but had a mentor/ supervisor to help us-

How many licensed or certified appraisers are looking fora trainee and can't find one.? How many do not need a trainee (not enough work) and how many simply don't WANT to take on a trainee? If anyone is looking for a trainee and can't find one something is bad wrong.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top