MrLA
Member
- Joined
- May 12, 2006
- Professional Status
- Certified Residential Appraiser
- State
- Louisiana
Read it carefully. If you can't identify the issue at hand, why would you need comps from an agent? If you have the knowledge, why would you need comps from an agent? The number one problem occurs when you go areas you are not familiar with. Wonder why some lenders want to know how many appraisals you performed in that neighborhood within the last year? That's my point. In my town, there is one area where some homes have shifted. Would an out of towner know this and wonder homes on a certain street sell for lower? Would an out of towner wonder why a house sold for less cause a large oak tree is over hanging a house or why a large lot can't be developed due to the trees? Are you familar with where the oil drllings are and how it impacts marketability? Are you familiar with where the school boundaries are? How about mello roos? Do you know which tracts have it and which don't? Are comps on the same street always the best comps? Two builders can build on the same street where I am from. Lol. See where I am, a hot looking agent will give an out of towner an appraisal package. They would straight blindside you with comps within a mile. Lol See I talk to these agents frequently. They tell me stories of how they got out of towners to bring in values and they laugh. Lol. That would lead to an incompetent report. My interpretation might be stricter than yours, but it makes sense. That's how out of towners get into trouble. Lack of knowledge leading into using disimlar sales, leading into an unsupported value. Just because you are an AG, doesn't give you the knowledge to do what ever you want. There is always something new to learn. Read a report you did last year. From 5 years and 10. Are your reports better now or the same?The fact that you are struggling with this topic AND supervising trainees is....concerning.
This is what USPAP actually says:
View attachment 58794
"can perform the assignment competently". Which will be demonstrated in the workproduct by actually performing the assignment competently.
If I know I can drop into a new-to-me neighborhood and perform the assignment competently then I can meet this requirement.
So "don't go where you are not competent" isn't a USPAP issue in particular. However, the GSEs have an additional requirement for the pre-existing market familiarity in Cert#11 - which that's what you're thinking about. That pre-existing familiarity is a user-driven requirement, not a USPAP requirement per se.
Nor is "asking a REAL professional" the only manner in which an appraiser can develop that competency. Matter of fact, if you or me or any other appraiser is working in a new-to-me area and we don't end up being more familiar with the total amount of relevant data than 90% of the RE brokers who work that area then we're screwing up. We're supposed to know what we're talking about in our appraisals.
Last edited: