Yes, they lowered the rating because the plan only cuts 2.4 trillion rather than at least 4 trillion demanded to avoid the downgrade. Of course S&P it turns out was overestimating the debt by 2 trillion so in actuality the cuts take the debt 400 billion below the level needed to avoid a downgrade. :new_all_coholic:
Got to love those ratings agencies.
The market has already discounted the downgrade, along with the creditability of S&P. Of course many will argue - and already have - that the record of ratings agencies such as Standard & Poor's of getting these things right in recent years has been lamentably poor. Think of all the subprime CDO products rated AAA by S&P that turned out to be garbage.
I believe investors are very much aware of the history of ALL credit rating agencies. I also believe that volatility in the world markets reflect the lack of credulity of governments to play a straight game. If anyone wanted to know the risk of default of bonds, they only have to consult the appropriate CDS (credit default swap) to see how the market rates them.
Cost of Protecting Treasurys Plummets On Debt Deal
http://online.wsj.com/article/BT-CO-20110801-709303.html
AUGUST 1, 2011, 10:30 A.M. ET
--Cost of one-year, five-year CDS is no longer inverted
--11th-hour deal on debt limit lowers near-term risk of default
--CDS-implied credit rating on US Treasurys is still AA
Credit-default-swap, or CDS, protection over the next 12 months is now cheaper than protection over five years, reversing a previous run-up in near-term CDS costs that had overtaken the cost of five-year protection when no such compromise was in sight. One-year and five-year CDS had been inverted through Friday night.
U.S. sovereign credit-default swaps are always quoted in euros, just as European sovereign swaps are quoted in dollars. This is because swap buyers seeking protection against a U.S. default want to protect themselves against the likelihood that the dollar would plunge if the government failed to pay its debts.
Monday's CDS levels now imply a credit rating of AA on U.S. Treasurys, lower than their current AAA rating and consistent with what some ratings companies believe is more appropriate for U.S. sovereign debt. Standard & Poor's, for example, has threatened to cut the U.S. credit rating if Congress doesn't produce viable austerity measures that will fix the U.S. deficit over the long term.
The debt deal reached over the weekend "doesn't get us past the downgrade hurdle," said Ian Lyngen, senior government bond strategist at CRT Capital Group LLC, "but now the rating agencies have something to work with."