• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Housing Bubble Bursting?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Home sales weak - no ifs, ands or buts

http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcon...N-recol_27bus.ART.State.Edition1.365c107.html
When the latest housing report showed that homes sales dropped in March by the biggest percentage since 1989, some industry analysts had a quick answer. They blamed the plunge on the weather.

What's next on the list of excuses for the falling sales? Sunspots? Halley's Comet?

How about something closer to the truth.

Thousands of potential homebuyers are taking a wait-and-see attitude about this year's housing market. And with good reason.

Home prices are in flux in many markets. And mortgage providers are tightening the screws on buyers.

Top homebuilders and some agents are warning that it will be several months before the country figures out which direction the housing market is going.

Of course, in the meantime, if you need to buy a house, go ahead. Mortgage rates are still very low, and homes are marked at discount prices in many markets.

And if buyers are being relocated by an employer or there's a baby on the way, they will proceed with their purchase – even if the weather is a bit dodgy.

Other potential purchasers who don't need to rush into the market may decide to take their time and let things settle out. Fair enough.

But industry boasting about how great the housing market is doing and rationalizing recent declines don't make consumers feel more confident.

I get a steady stream of press releases bragging about the "booming" housing market. The message must have been delayed in the mail for a year or two.

If anything, false bravado makes buyers more skeptical about current market conditions.

Consumers are pretty good at sorting things out. They'll decide which direction the housing market is going – regardless of what the cheerleaders and doomsayers have to say
 
Homebuilders: A Tale of Two Stocks

http://www.elliottwave.com/features/default.aspx?cat=emw*aid=3019*time=am
This is from a recent public online forum on Google Finance:

Investor A: If you have not noticed, the homebuilders stock is starting to show signs of life. We had predicted 2007 would be when this sector starts its recovery…

Investor B: I can't agree more. When homebuilders are offering incentives over $40k on each home, it has to be a great time to buy homebuilder stock.

Investor C: You must be joking.

My initial reaction after I'd read the email exchange above was – I'm with you, Investor C. Anyone who recommends homebuilders' stocks at a time when the subprime mortgage crisis threatens to leave over 2 million American families homeless and "cost American households as much as $164 billion in lost equity from 1998 through 2006" must be joking. (CNN Money)
 
Recession? U.S. Economy Expanded at a 1.3% Annual Rate in First Quarter

http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601068&sid=abS2Lctm5deE&refer=economy

April 27 (Bloomberg) -- The U.S. economy grew in the first quarter at the slowest pace in four years, hobbled by the slump in home construction and a bigger trade deficit.


The 1.3 percent annual growth rate was less than forecast and followed a 2.5 percent fourth-quarter pace, the Commerce Department reported today in Washington. A measure of inflation watched by the Federal Reserve rose at a faster pace.


Consumer spending kept the expansion alive as the slowdown in housing extended to a sixth quarter, the longest continuous slide in a generation. A burst of inflation last quarter will prevent Federal Reserve policy makers from lowering interest rates to stimulate growth, economists said.


``The Fed was correct in identifying the elevated downside risks to economy,'' Michael Gregory, a senior economist at BMO Nesbitt Burns in Toronto, said before the report. ``But they are prepared to wait it out.''


Last quarter's growth rate was the weakest since the first three months of 2003. Growth in the 12 months ended in March slowed to 2.1 percent, the weakest year-over-year gain since the second quarter of 2003.

Before adjusting for inflation, the economy expanded at a 5.3 percent annual pace last quarter, up from 4.1 percent.

A jump in oil last quarter pushed up prices. The report's price index rose at an annual rate of 4 percent, the most since 1991, compared with 1.7 percent in the fourth quarter.


The Fed's preferred inflation measure, which is tied to consumer spending and strips out food and energy costs, rose at a 2.2 percent annual rate, up from a 1.8 percent fourth-quarter gain. Fed Chairman Ben S. Bernanke is among policy makers that have said a 1 percent to 2 percent increase is preferable.


Consumer spending, which accounts for about 70 percent of the economy, rose at an annual rate of 3.8 percent last quarter, compared with a 4.2 percent pace in the previous three months. Before today's report, quarterly consumer-spending gains averaged 3.7 percent the past decade.


Home construction fell at an annual rate of 17 percent last quarter, after contracting by 19.8 percent in the previous three months. The decline subtracted 1 percentage point from first- quarter growth. The last time spending on home construction dropped for six consecutive quarters was in the early 1980s.

A jump in subprime-mortgage defaults and foreclosures heighten the risk that the real estate slump will linger, economists said. Signs have emerged that woes in manufacturing and housing are suppressing demand in other industries.
 
U.S. Consumer Spending May Take a Hit as Americans See Home Prices Decline

http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601068&sid=aFhxqtaoKDMA&refer=economy

April 27 (Bloomberg) -- Carol Francis says her customers are less likely to make big furniture purchases these days than they were at the height of the housing boom two years ago.


``The housing market right now is affecting everybody's spending,'' said Francis, a design consultant at Thomasville Home Furnishings in Woodbridge, Virginia, 25 miles south of Washington. Before, ``I had people who would buy two and three bedrooms of furniture. Now many come in and just buy one piece at a time.''


With home prices in danger of falling this year for the first time in at least four decades, Americans are turning wary about borrowing against their houses to pay for vacations, education or remodeling projects. In a reversal of the ``wealth effect,'' people who once viewed soaring home values as a rationalization for higher spending appear to be pulling back.


``We're in a housing recession; it's not over and it's going to spread to other parts of the economy, mainly consumer spending,'' said Paul Kasriel, director of economic research at Northern Trust Securities in Chicago.

``House prices are going to continue to fall, and that's going to play havoc with consumers because it means the home ATM is now draining, it's no longer filling.''

While home sales and construction have been falling for more than a year, the secondary impact on consumer spending, which accounts for 70 percent of the economy, may just be kicking in.


Kevin Logan, senior market economist at Dresdner Kleinwort in New York, says the reverse wealth effect will subtract about 0.7 percentage point from consumer-spending growth this year. He expects spending in the fourth quarter to be 2.7 percent higher than a year earlier, compared with growth of 3.6 percent in the fourth quarter of 2006.

The first quarter may have been the consumer's last fling. The Commerce Department reported today that personal consumption grew at a 3.8 percent annual rate in January through March. Spending growth is projected to slow to an average 2.5 percent annual pace in the last three quarters of 2007, according to the median estimate of economists surveyed this month.


Francis, 44, said the housing slump has prompted her to change her own home-remodeling plans. ``It does affect me,'' she said. ``I've slowed the renovation work.''


She says furniture sales have been weakening for more than a year. ``A lot of people bought houses at a time when they were making $200,000, $300,000'' on the sale of their previous homes, Francis said. Now, they have ``these big, beautiful homes, but there is no meat in the freezer.''
Some homeowners are strapped as their mortgage payments increase after low ``teaser'' rates expire.
 
Mortgage Woes Send FBR to Quarterly Loss

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/04/26/AR2007042602630.html

"This has been an extremely difficult operating environment for the entire non-prime mortgage banking industry, and it has resulted in a series of distressed sales and bankruptcies," Eric F. Billings, FBR chairman and chief executive, said in a news release. "We believe that FNLC's management has taken aggressive steps designed to limit foreseeable major risks with respect to the business."

A large number of investment houses spent millions of dollars to buy mortgage lenders from 2003 to 2005, enjoying a share of the seemingly endless line of home buyers qualifying for mortgages they otherwise could not afford because lending standards were looser.

"Now they are realizing they overpaid, and they're trying to unload them," said James Croft, founder of the Mortgage Asset Research Institute in Reston. "It looked like you could make a lot of money, and you could. But they stayed in the game too long."
 
Fed Officials Stay Focused on Inflation Risks

http://www.cnbc.com/id/18348296

Inflationary pressures in the U.S. economy are likely to ebb but there is not enough proof in the data so far to feel reassured, Federal Reserve officials said on Thursday.

And with risks to both inflation and growth on the rise, policy-makers gave no indication they plan a change to the Fed's steady-as-she-goes stance on interest rates.

"The best course for policy is watchful waiting," San Francisco Fed President Janet Yellen said late on Thursday in a speech to the Money Marketeers of New York University.


"The current stance of policy is likely to foster sustainable growth with a gradual ebbing of inflation over time. However, the inflation risks are skewed to the upside," Yellen said.


Earlier, Richard Fisher, the Dallas Fed president, told a group of investment advisers in Austin that he wants to see "verified" a reduction in inflation trends and expectations.


Fisher and Yellen spoke less than two weeks before the next scheduled meeting of the U.S. central bank's policy-setting Federal Open Market Committee on May 9. Neither is a voting member of the FOMC this year.


Financial markets expect the Fed to hold its benchmark fed funds rate at 5.25 percent at least through its May and June meetings. The FOMC last raised interest rates in June 2006.
 
Countrywide / Indymac blame subprime credit woes

http://www.cnbc.com/id/18349524/for/cnbc/

NEW YORK - The subprime mortgage shakeout has spooked investors so much that the nation's two biggest mortgage lenders, which have relatively low exposure to borrowers with bad credit, recently reported lower first-quarter profits due to payment defaults.

Countrywide Financial Corp. and Indymac Bancorp Inc., which are both based in California, reported Thursday that first-quarter profit fell by more than a third. Even though neither mortgage bank issues more than 10 percent of its loans to subprime borrowers, the banks blamed subprime credit woes for the profit deterioration.

A confluence of factors earlier this year squeezed credit quality among risky borrowers. Home prices slumped, blocking people's access to money through refinancing. The Federal Reserve's interest rate hikes pushed up monthly payments on adjustable-rate loans, forcing some borrowers into payment shock.

With missed payments on the rise, the investors who buy mortgage banks' loans in the secondary market began shying away from risky debt. As the debt lost value, many mortgage lenders' financial backers pulled the plug because those loans acted as collateral for credit lines.

Countrywide Financial's chief executive, Angelo Mozilo, said more than 30 subprime lenders have gone out of business this year.

As many analysts feared, the fallout in subprime home lending has spread into other types of mortgage debt. The market for mortgages has fewer buyers and less liquidity, leading to lower prices for debt carrying any type of risk.

Indymac and Countrywide both cut their profit outlooks because of the pressure from subprime credit.

Keefe, Bruyette & Woods analyst Frederick Cannon downgraded Countrywide to "Underperform" from "Market Perform." Mortgage banks are enacting stricter standards to avoid lending to people who can't repay the loans, which Cannon said poses higher costs for lenders.
 
I have a lender client I have been doing work for about 21 years. They have one of those borrowers that took the “how to get rich in real estate” course back in the early 1970’s. The first time I butted heads with this idiot was back in the 70’s. This dude has never had a regular job and for the last 30 years has lived off property appreciation and financing/refi schemes. I could sit here all day and tell you stores on this person and the experiences I have had with him. I knew that one day in the future judgment day was coming for him.
Well judgment has arrived. They foreclosed on all of his property this month and bought back most of it. When prices stopped going up and he could no longer refinance there was no motive to keep going. He couldn’t live off the rental income and make payments too. The bank held all of the trustee sales week before last. Tuesday I received a strange request from the bank. They had a buyer for two of the properties and wanted me to appraise them. I said OK, what is the sale price? They said this deal is different. This is a job for the bank. We want you to tell us what the property is really worth so we will know what kind of exposure we are faced with in this sale. I turned the reports in yesterday. There reply was: “Boy, we are going to have a hard time explaining this.” I asked why? They replied that based on what they have sold the properties to another “get rich in real estate jockey for” they would be in for 200% loan exposure based on my appraisals.
If in the same situation that is exactly what I would do. Keep the music playing just like what the GSE’s and congresses are going to do and dance around this dilemma. Pass the problem off to some other idiot by giving them the same liberal loan terms and conditions that got the last idiot busted. It is called musical banking. I had a long talk with one of the LO’s. He knew all about the mortgage crap shoot and how it works. I must admit that this lender is possibly one of the most sane in the country and their loan loss is historically insignificant. At least it has been for the last 21 years.
Mean while back at the ranch! This area is economically depressed with high unemployment and population decline and the powers that be are trying to turn the area into a major retail hub to create new jobs. Huge new 450,000 sf anchor complex just started the grading to employ around 1,500. Had two front page newspaper stories about it this week. Both stories based on interviews with two different spoke persons from the developer. One used the number 340,000 and one 350,000 as the number of people within a 1 hour drive time necessary to make the project feasible. Didn’t sound right to me so after reading the first news account I did a brief market analysis of my own. I used a 45 minute drive time and came up with 237,000 people. The southern end of the line was inside the city limits of a huge metro area that is the largest retail super hub in the region and in the other direction ended just south of another metro area far larger than this city. To get the population numbers they are talking about would require going deeper into larger metro area to the south and right into the heart of their huge retail area. That is where the people are. There is no way this is even close to being rational. I mailed a map of the 45 minute drive time and demographic analysis of the area to the reporter. Never heard back. If I adjusted the numbers by market analysis methods if it hit 150,000 people it would be a miracle.
My point is: “We are right in the middle of one bubble and the same idiots are in the process of creating another one in another market segment. What the hell is the point of it all? The tax payers will end bailing them all out in the long run.
 
Last edited:
Just from the news accounts of the last few days, it looks like a lot of the RE people are going back into the stock market.
 
http://biz.yahoo.com/ap/070427/economy.html?.v=2


Economic Growth in 1Q Slows to 1.3 Pct.
Friday April 27, 9:36 am ET
By Jeannine Aversa, AP Economics Writer

WASHINGTON (AP) -- Economic growth slowed to a near crawl of 1.3 percent in the first three months of 2007, the worst performance in four years. The main culprit: the housing slump.
The fresh reading on gross domestic product, released by the Commerce Department on Friday, was even weaker than the 2.5 percent growth rate logged in the final three months of last year. The new figures underscored just how much momentum the economy has been losing as it copes with the strain of the troubled housing market, which has made some businesses more cautious in their spending.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top