• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Are Staff Appraisers paid customary and reasonable fees?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I never thought it was another employees business what I was paid nor was it any of my business what they were paid.
Why not? You're on a team doing the same work. Only in america is it taboo to talk about how much you make. It's really weird. Nobody cares in Europe. How can you spot unfair treatment if nobody talks about payment?
 
When you work for yourself, nobody tells you what to do and nobody takes a cut of your labor. I accept those 'cheap' orders with pride! I have pride in my work. I wouldn't accept an order if I didn't want it.

My problem with the workplace environment is that you get equal pay for unequal work. The person who goes above and beyond is not rewarded with more pay. I learned this at my very first job at Jewel Osco. I cleaned the shelves so well that my boss made me clean shelves ALL DAY once a week. He specifically told me so.
Clearly, you have been abused. Sorry for that. But, I get a distinct impression that you may well have earned much of that (at least as much as you might have earned everything you think you may have but didn't receive). Sometimes, life is hard!
 
Why not? You're on a team doing the same work. Only in america is it taboo to talk about how much you make. It's really weird. Nobody cares in Europe. How can you spot unfair treatment if nobody talks about payment?
Let's say I interview and hire you. WE negotiate a pay rate. What has that got to do with my other agreements, from your standpoint?

You don't like the situation? Give notice and move on.

By "sluffing off" from 3 o'clock on you give the impression to others you are not earning your wages, just as you may feel about them.

Me, I got the attitude you would be gone if you were not willing to produce as WE agreed upon when you were hired.

Good luck. Please don't let the door hit you on the way out.
 
I am currently working for an AMC as a staff appraiser doing desktop valuations. The appraisers in our department are getting paid close to nothing for each appraisal (as low as $14 ea.) Does anyone know if staff appraisers fall under the customary and reasonable fees requirements?

You know, it is a free country. If you are working for someone else and the salary is simply not paying the bills, nor paying for your retirement, or providing you with experience you can use to get a better job, then you should leave and work elsewhere or in a different profession.

Right now, being a residential appraiser sucks for most. The work simply is not there. It comes and goes. IF you want to be an appraiser, you need to have a second or even third profession that is related. You should think of yourself as providing "Real Estate Services". You should be able to jump into Surveying and Mapping (there is plenty of work here without being a licensed surveyor), Photography (aerial, architectural, etc.), CAD house plans (i.e. House Designer), IT, Inspection, Sales, and so on.

Most jobs require a certain degree of competence. If you have a certain natural talent, they can be easy jobs But, most jobs require dealing with people - above you, at your level, and below your level. To be successful in the long term, you need to be able to communicate and negotiate, in addition to being competent at executing the work you are supposed to do.

That is to say, most other workers around you have their own assigned or unassigned tasks to deal with. When conflicts arise between what they think they need to do or have, and what you think you need for your job, conflicts arise. So, even if you have some natural talent, you will inevitably find the going difficult at times. Can you handle such stress in addition to being good at the core skills needed just for your profession?

1. Certain kinds of jobs are "glamour" jobs, they are attractive to certain kinds of people for one reason or the other, aside from salary and benefits. Often these so-called glamour jobs just push workers into poverty and even destitution. You will find divorced and bankrupt MAIs, good MAIs - who are however simply bad at business or bad at dealing with people. Such jobs for some people - lead to poor health, high divorce rates, and so on. From a social perspective, such jobs are satisfactory as temporary jobs - but if such workers can't climb out of them, they eventually become a burden on society. Sooner or later. - One BIG category here, is simply people who absolutely insist on working independently - but who are really not capable of executing all of the skills needed to survive as an independent for the long haul. [ To run your own business and make a profit, you had better be good at self-promotion, sales and dealing with customers. In particular, the words "multi-tasking" and "boring work" come to mind. If you want to be a specialist who ONLY does interesting work (like yours truly), you had better be rich, retired - or work for a large company that appreciates your talent.]

2. There are also the "homeless" jobs that work really well for certain people, especially those who are completely incapable of getting along with other people in the world of work. You know, people with distinct personality disorders and the like. These are people others don't want to be around for any length of time, because of that black cloud hanging over them, - that sooner or later becomes contrary survival of the "others." OF COURSE, the rest of us don't appreciate the homeless setting up tents on public sidewalks, writing graffiti on public structures, or otherwise polluting the environment. Society is still learning how to deal with the homeless, who are likely to be a continuing and growing problem.
 
Let's say I interview and hire you. WE negotiate a pay rate. What has that got to do with my other agreements, from your standpoint?
I have personal ethics. If someone is being paid less for the same work, that's not fair. I don't like being treated unfairly. As a boss, I wouldn't do that. In general, humans hate being treated unfairly.

Of course the capitalist doesn't want the workers to come together and discuss wages. The capitalist wants to pay each employee as little as possible for their labor. It's called being a good businessman.
 
Would you want to associate yourself with a company that pays workers unfairly? You're response is going to be "they signed up for it!" So? It's still wrong. People used to sign themselves up for slavery because they were so desperate. You'd probably support that because it was consensual ROFL.
 
I am currently working for an AMC as a staff appraiser doing desktop valuations. The appraisers in our department are getting paid close to nothing for each appraisal (as low as $14 ea.) Does anyone know if staff appraisers fall under the customary and reasonable fees requirements?
Yes, your company is probably getting C&R fees for these types of products... But they are keeping the majority of the money.
 
Staff appraisers have always been paid less than a busy fee appraiser could do for themselves. And then they get laid off when the volumes dry up, which puts them out into the fee appraisal business at the worst possible time. The only exception will by govt employment.

Nothing happens at an AMC that isn't condoned, enabled and at times demanded by the lenders for which they work. AFAICT the AMC business is far more competitive than the fee appraisal business.
 
I have personal ethics. If someone is being paid less for the same work, that's not fair. I don't like being treated unfairly. As a boss, I wouldn't do that. In general, humans hate being treated unfairly.

Of course the capitalist doesn't want the workers to come together and discuss wages. The capitalist wants to pay each employee as little as possible for their labor. It's called being a good businessman.
My question is why do you care-if this is a real Social warrior Issue why not go work for EDD or some agencie that is involved in labor law. As a fee appraiser your opinions or ideologues have virtually no impact on labor laws . I also do not believe you will make a good employer and should stick to being a sole owner. Social Warriors need to get Govt Jobs or become a union member and leader .
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top